top of page
חיפוש

Parashat Toldot: Can Someone Be Born Evil? Racism, Indoctrination, and Educating Children in God's Name

9 בנוב׳
זמן קריאה 9 דקות

Would you allow someone to teach your children that a person can be evil before birth simply because God has declared it so?


And what would you say if your children were told that people from another nation are inherently dishonest, that a woman's primary purpose is to bear sons, and that their deceased grandparents will soon rise from their graves?


I suspect many of you would be appalled.


But what happens when those same messages appear in religious stories intended for children?


Does calling a tradition sacred suddenly transform its messages into moral education?


In this segment from Episode 203 of Beliefs & Consequences, Parashat Toldot, I examine these questions through religious educational materials based on rabbinic stories.


The problem is not the existence of ancient stories, or even the fact that they contain strange, cruel, or implausible ideas. Every culture has its mythology.


The problem begins when children are told that these stories represent unquestionable truth and that they must adopt the values expressed in them.


Because beliefs have consequences.


Esau: Wicked Before He Has Done Anything


In Parashat Toldot, in the Book of Genesis, we encounter Isaac and Rebecca and their twin sons, Jacob and Esau.


Rebecca experiences a difficult pregnancy. The children struggle within her, and she seeks an explanation. The biblical answer is that two nations are in her womb, two peoples will emerge from her, and the older will serve the younger.


That is the biblical narrative.


But rabbinic interpretations add an entire world of meaning.


In the educational materials I examine, Rebecca passes places of religious study, and one fetus struggles to emerge because he supposedly wants to study Torah. When she passes places associated with idol worship, the other fetus struggles to emerge.


Thus, two unborn children, neither of whom has done anything, become one righteous and the other wicked.


Consider the educational implications.


What makes someone wicked? Is it harmful actions? A deliberate decision to hurt others?


Conduct that we can examine and judge?


Not here.


Here, wickedness exists before action. It is supposedly part of a child's identity before birth.


Children hearing this narrative may learn that they do not need to know a person, examine their behavior, or understand their circumstances. They need only know which group that person belongs to.


If someone said the same thing about Jews, would we accept the explanation that it was merely a traditional story?


How Do You Turn a Baby Into a Monster?


The rabbinic portrayal of Esau does not stop at declaring him wicked.


He is described as unusually red and hairy, with extraordinary physical characteristics. In the educational narrative discussed in this segment, the description expands to include a beard, mustache, and a snake-like marking on his leg.


In other words, not only is Esau's character portrayed as defective. His physical appearance becomes evidence of supposed evil.


This is a familiar mechanism of dehumanization.


When people want to portray an individual or group as inherently threatening, it becomes easier if they describe them as strange, frightening, ugly, or monstrous.


Instead of seeing a baby, children are taught to see a monster.


Instead of asking what someone has done, they are taught to consider what that person supposedly is by nature.


And I ask: Who created this monster?


The infant, who has never had an opportunity to make a choice? Or the people who chose to tell this story about him?


We must distinguish between the biblical text and later interpretation. Genesis does describe Esau as red and hairy, but some of the more monstrous details in these educational narratives are later interpretive additions, not explicit descriptions in the biblical verses.


That distinction matters. Our criticism must be accurate. We do not need to attribute things to scripture that it does not actually say in order to demonstrate how troubling certain interpretations can be.


Rebecca, Isaac, and the Status of Women


Before the twins are born, the educational materials discussed in the episode return to the marriage of Isaac and Rebecca.


According to a chronological calculation found in certain traditional interpretations, Rebecca was three years old when she married Isaac, who was forty.


This is not an established historical fact about Rebecca's age. Nor does the Bible explicitly state that she was three. It is a traditional interpretation based on calculations of biblical chronology.


But when such a calculation is presented to children as part of a religious lesson, we must ask what understanding of childhood, marriage, and women's status it conveys.


The story then describes Isaac and Rebecca struggling to have children for many years.


The religious explanation offered is that God loves hearing the prayers of righteous people and therefore withholds children until they pray.


What picture of God does this present?


An all-powerful being who could grant people what they desire but chooses to prolong their suffering because he enjoys their prayers?


And that is not all.


In the account of Isaac's prayer, the possibility arises that he may have to take another wife if Rebecca cannot give birth.


The woman becomes an instrument for continuing the family line. The man is the center of the narrative, the divine promise concerns him and his descendants, and the woman is evaluated primarily according to her ability to fulfill the role assigned to her.


Are these the values we want to pass on to children today?


Red Stew, the Birthright, and Resurrection


We all know the story of the hungry Esau returning from the field and asking Jacob for the red stew.


Jacob takes advantage of the opportunity to obtain Esau's birthright.


But in the educational story examined in this segment, another layer of religious teaching is added.


Esau questions the value of righteousness if even the righteous Abraham has died. Jacob responds that the dead will be resurrected, and Esau expresses disbelief.


A story about hunger, stew, and inheritance becomes a lesson about the obligation to believe in resurrection.


The particularly interesting part is the guidance given to parents.


The educational material discussed in the segment recommends reminding children of deceased relatives and explaining that those relatives will return to life.


Imagine a child who has lost a beloved grandmother.


The child misses her and may still be struggling to understand death. Then someone says that Grandma will return soon, when the Messiah arrives.


Is that an appropriate way to comfort a child? Is it a promise anyone can responsibly make? Is the child told that this is a religious belief, or is it presented as an established fact?


I have no objection to people believing in resurrection. They have every right to hold their own beliefs.


But there is an enormous difference between personal faith and presenting an unverifiable proposition to children as an absolute certainty, particularly when those children are grieving.


Abimelech, the Philistines, and the Claim That Non-Jews Lie


Later in the episode, we reach the story of the covenant between Isaac and Abimelech.


According to the narrative, following disputes over wells, Abimelech approaches Isaac, and they establish an agreement not to harm one another.


This story could be used to teach reconciliation, negotiation, and the possibility of overcoming conflict.


But in the educational material I discuss, it becomes an opportunity to convey a very different message.


The Philistines are portrayed as failing to honor their promises, and the lesson expands into a sweeping generalization about non-Jews: they supposedly do not tell the truth, whereas the Jewish people, possessing the Torah, supposedly never lie.


Notice the transition.


A description of the behavior of particular people becomes a declaration about everyone who is not Jewish.


That is precisely how prejudice becomes a worldview.


There is no need to know the individual. No need to examine their behavior. Belonging to the wrong group is sufficient.


And here I return to my earlier question.


If someone taught children that all Jews are inherently dishonest, what would we call that message?


Why should the same generalization become acceptable when we change the group being discussed?


"God Always Saves Us": What About History?


The educational narrative continues by assuring children that God always protects the Jewish people from their enemies.


Always.


That is an extraordinary word.


Can we seriously use it in light of Jewish history?


What about the pogroms? The expulsions? The persecutions? And what about the Holocaust?


Six million Jews were murdered during the Holocaust, including approximately 1.5 million children.


How can anyone present the claim that God always saves the Jewish people as a straightforward historical fact?


One might argue that divine protection operates in mysterious ways, or that religious promises do not apply to every individual and every event.


Those are theological positions that can be discussed.


But they are not equivalent to historical evidence.


When a claim about reality conflicts with the evidence, we have no right to erase the evidence to preserve the claim.


History is not obligated to conform to our beliefs. Our beliefs must be examined in light of history.


What Is Indoctrination, and Why Does It Matter?


To understand the criticism in this episode, several terms deserve clarification.


• Indoctrination: A process through which people are taught to accept a system of beliefs as authoritative while opportunities for critical examination are restricted. The distinction between education and indoctrination is not whether beliefs are presented, but whether those beliefs may be questioned.


• Midrash: Jewish interpretive literature that expands upon biblical texts, sometimes through stories, parables, and details not explicitly found in scripture.


• Chazal: A Hebrew acronym meaning "Our Sages of Blessed Memory," generally referring to the rabbis of the Mishnah and Talmud and related traditions.


• Racism: Beliefs or practices assigning characteristics, value, or status to people based on racial or ethnic origin. Similar generalizations based on religion or nationality may also constitute prejudice, xenophobia, or group-based discrimination.


• Dehumanization: Portraying human beings as less than human, as animals, or as monsters, potentially making it easier to deny their dignity and rights.


• Resurrection of the dead: The religious belief that deceased people will return to life in the future. It appears in various Jewish traditions and is included among Maimonides' principles of faith.


• Idolatry: A Jewish religious term for prohibited forms of worship, including worship of other gods or images in certain contexts.


• Birthright: The special status of a family's firstborn son, potentially involving inheritance rights, authority, and social position.


These concepts are not merely academic.

They help us understand how stories influence the ways people think, educate, and behave.


We Can Teach Tradition Without Teaching Prejudice


I want to make something clear.


There is no need to hide biblical stories or rabbinic interpretations from children. Quite the opposite. We can study them, investigate them, compare different versions, and understand their cultural and historical backgrounds.


But we can also ask questions.


Was Esau really evil from birth?


Does someone's family background or national identity determine their moral worth?


Should a woman's value be measured by her ability to have children?


Is it acceptable to promise a child that a deceased grandfather will soon return to life?


Can we claim that an entire group of human beings is inherently dishonest?


And does a religious proposition become true merely because generations of people have believed it?


Proper education does not require children to accept one answer that must never be challenged.


Proper education gives them the tools to question, investigate, compare, doubt, and reach their own conclusions.


A child taught to think is not a threat to truth. That child threatens only those who fear questions.


Watch the Segment From Episode 203: Parashat Toldot


In this new segment from Beliefs & Consequences, I examine these educational materials, their relationship to rabbinic interpretations, and their potential consequences for how children understand morality, identity, and belonging.


The discussion is not merely about stories told thousands of years ago. It concerns what children continue to be taught today.


Watch the full segment from Episode 203, Parashat Toldot, on our YouTube channel:


If this discussion makes you think, subscribe to the channel, like the video, share it, and explain in the comments where you agree with me and where you believe I am wrong.


Sources, Biblical Passages, and Further Reading


The following sources allow readers to examine the narratives and claims discussed in the segment. They include biblical texts, interpretive traditions, and historical references. Not every detail in a midrash should be treated as a historical account of an event that actually occurred.


• Genesis 25:19–34: Rebecca's pregnancy, the birth of Jacob and Esau, and the sale of the birthright. Read on Sefaria


• Genesis 26: Isaac, Abimelech, the wells, and the covenant at Beersheba. Read on Sefaria


• Rashi on Genesis 25:20: The traditional chronological calculation suggesting that Rebecca was three years old when she married Isaac. Read Rashi on Sefaria


• Rashi on Genesis 25:22: The interpretation of the twins' movements in relation to places of Torah study and idolatry. Read Rashi on Sefaria


• Genesis Rabbah 63: Rabbinic traditions concerning Rebecca's pregnancy, Jacob, and Esau. Read on Sefaria


• Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1: Discussion of resurrection and the world to come. Read on Sefaria


• Maimonides, Commentary on the Mishnah, Introduction to Perek Chelek: The principles of faith, including resurrection. Explore relevant sources on Sefaria


• Yad Vashem: Historical documentation, research, and educational materials concerning the Holocaust. Official website


The biblical and rabbinic references are provided for independent examination. The analysis of the modern educational materials is based on the narratives presented in the video segment.


In Conclusion: The Question Is Not Only What We Believe, but What We Do With Those Beliefs


The stories we tell children do not exist in a vacuum.


They influence how children learn to understand themselves, other people, and the world.


When we teach a child that someone can be evil from birth, we risk diminishing the importance of actions and free choice.


When we teach that an entire group of people is dishonest, we risk cultivating prejudice.


When we teach that religious claims must never be questioned, we risk undermining a child's ability to examine reality independently.


Therefore, my central question in Parashat Toldot is not whether these stories are ancient, interesting, or sacred.


The question is what happens when we turn them into moral lessons for children.


Because beliefs have consequences.

 
 
 

פוסטים אחרונים

הצג הכול
פרשת תולדות: האם אפשר להיוולד רשע? על גזענות, אינדוקטרינציה וחינוך ילדים בשם אלוהים

האם הייתם מוכנים שמישהו ילמד את ילדיכם שאדם יכול להיות רשע עוד לפני שנולד, רק משום שאלוהים קבע כך? ומה הייתם אומרים אילו סיפרו לילדים שלכם שבני עם אחר אינם דוברי אמת מטבעם, שאישה נועדה בעיקר ללדת בנים

 
 
 

תגובות

דירוג של 0 מתוך 5 כוכבים
אין עדיין דירוגים

הוספת דירוג

הישארו מעודכנים בחדשות ובפרקים האחרונים

!תודה ששלחת את המידע שלך

מידע על הזמנות

תרצו להתארח לשיחה בפודקאסט?

האם תרצו שדניאל אדר יתארח בתכנית הפודקאסט,
הרדיו או הטלוויזיה שלכם?

צרו איתנו קשר עוד היום!

עקבו אחרינו

  • YouTube
  • White Facebook Icon
  • Instagram
  • Patreon
  • B&CP_Substack logo icon for website-White

© 2021-2026 by Beliefs & Consequences Media. Website designed and managed by Yolanda Hairston Adar. 

View on desktop for best experience.

bottom of page